Fashion Weekly
The Era of Celebrity Beauty Brands: Are They Worth the Hype?

Celebrity beauty brands have surged in popularity in recent years, transforming Hollywood’s biggest names into beauty moguls. From skincare to cosmetics, these celebrity brands have changed the landscape, with loyal fan bases and sometimes millions in returns. Yet, as the market becomes more saturated, customers are beginning to ask: are these products worth the price, or is it just star power at work?

Celebrity Skincare, Hair Care, and Makeup Brands

Celebrity-driven skincare, hair care, and makeup brands have captured the spotlight, bringing both glamour and influence to the beauty industry. From Rihanna’s Fenty Beauty revolutionizing inclusivity in makeup to Selena Gomez’s Rare Beauty promoting mental health awareness through beauty, these brands have quickly gained loyal followings.

Celebrities leverage their personal appeal to create unique brands, often bringing fresh, innovative formulas to the market. For instance, Gwyneth Paltrow’s Goop has made waves in natural skincare, while Kim Kardashian’s SKKN offers high-end solutions for skin wellness. In the haircare space, Tracee Ellis Ross’s Pattern Beauty has resonated for its dedication to textured hair, while Jennifer Lopez’s JLo Beauty delivers a mix of skincare and makeup that aligns with her personal style and approach to beauty.

These brands are not only recognized for their trendsetting products but also their financial success, often turning their celebrity founders into powerhouse names in the beauty business.

Why Celebrities Are Entering the Beauty Market

In the social media age, personal branding has become a powerful tool, allowing celebrities to directly engage with audiences. Beauty brands have become a natural extension, with many stars, as influencers,  use their visibility to promote products that promise to capture their signature look or philosophy.

The financial payoff for celebrities can be massive. Beauty is a lucrative industry with a relatively high margin, allowing celebrities to rake in substantial profits. According to Forbes, celebrity beauty brands can reach valuations of hundreds of millions in just a few years, driven by dedicated fans and effective branding.

Successful Celebrity Beauty Brands and Their Financial Success

1. Fenty Beauty by Rihanna

  • Launched: 2017
  • Estimated Value: Over $2.8 billion
  • Financial Returns: Rihanna’s Fenty Beauty was a game-changer, achieving $100 million in sales within its first 40 days. Today, the brand is valued in the billions, and Fenty’s success made Rihanna a billionaire.
  • Product Quality: Fenty’s focus on inclusivity with a wide range of shades has set a new standard in the beauty industry, especially for foundation. The brand's quality is highly rated, and many products receive positive reviews for both their performance and innovative shades.

2. Kylie Cosmetics by Kylie Jenner

  • Launched: 2015
  • Estimated Value: $900 million (partial sale in 2019 valued at $1.2 billion)
  • Financial Returns: Kylie Jenner built her brand around her signature lip kits, turning her popularity into a near-billion-dollar empire. In 2019, she sold 51% of Kylie Cosmetics to Coty Inc. for $600 million.
  • Product Quality: While Kylie Cosmetics has been praised for trendy colours and affordability, some reviewers have noted inconsistencies in quality, particularly with limited edition launches. However, it remains popular due to its affordability and easy-to-use products.

3. Rare Beauty by Selena Gomez

  • Launched: 2020
  • Estimated Value: Over $1 billion
  • Financial Returns: Rare Beauty has achieved rapid success, surpassing $100 million in sales in its first year. The brand’s message of inclusivity and mental health has resonated deeply with consumers.
  • Product Quality: Rare Beauty has been well-received for its high-quality products, particularly the Soft Pinch Liquid Blush and Liquid Touch Foundation, known for their smooth application and inclusivity in shade range. Many fans also appreciate its skincare approach to makeup, focusing on lightweight and natural finishes.

4. Florence by Mills by Millie Bobby Brown

  • Launched: 2019
  • Target Audience: Gen Z
  • Financial Returns: The brand has found a solid audience among young consumers. While it may not be as financially dominant as Fenty or Rare Beauty, Florence by Mills has shown strong potential and popularity within its niche.
  • Product Quality: As a skincare line, Florence by Mills has mixed reviews. The products are designed to be gentle and accessible for younger users, but some consumers feel they’re too mild for certain skin types. Still, it has earned a dedicated fanbase among teenagers looking for entry-level skin care.

5. JLo Beauty by Jennifer Lopez

  • Launched: 2021
  • Estimated Value: Not disclosed, but reported as profitable
  • Financial Returns: Although JLo Beauty is relatively new, it has shown profitable results, targeting the luxury skin care market.
  • Product Quality: JLo Beauty emphasizes skin care products intended to achieve Lopez’s famously glowing skin, but reviews are mixed. The brand’s higher price point has attracted criticism, with some consumers finding certain products too expensive for the results.

6. Anomaly by Priyanka Chopra Jonas

  • Launched: 2021
  • Estimated Value: $15 million (first year)
  • Financial Returns: Anomaly has seen steady growth by addressing the demand for affordable and sustainable hair care. Positioned as an accessible brand, it quickly resonated with eco-conscious consumers in both the U.S. and international markets.
  • Product Quality: Anomaly’s hair care line has been praised for its clean ingredients and focus on sustainability. With recyclable packaging and formulas free from harmful chemicals, Anomaly offers high-quality hair care at an affordable price, making it a standout among celebrity brands for environmentally-minded customers.

7. R.E.M. Beauty by Ariana Grande

  • Launched: 2021
  • Estimated Value: $60 million
  • Financial Returns: R.E.M. Beauty has experienced significant initial success, particularly in the U.S. and Europe, as Grande’s large fanbase eagerly embraced the brand. Sales were bolstered by product launches focused on high-demand items, quickly establishing R.E.M. as a competitive brand in the celebrity makeup market.
  • Product Quality: Known for its playful and bold aesthetic, R.E.M. Beauty has received positive reviews for its quality, especially for items like the Midnight Shadows eyeshadow and On Your Collar plumping lip gloss. Fans appreciate the brand’s blend of pop-inspired colours and effective formulations that cater to versatile looks, from casual to glam.

Pros and Cons of Celebrity Beauty Brands

Pros

  • Built-in Trust: Fans often feel connected to celebrities they admire and may trust their product recommendations.
  • Marketing Power: Celebrities can leverage their social media influence, cutting down on traditional marketing costs.
  • Diversity and Inclusivity: Many brands prioritize inclusivity, particularly in shade ranges, making products accessible to a wider range of skin tones and types.

Cons

  • Inconsistent Quality: Not all celebrity brands maintain high-quality standards across product lines, with some being rushed to capitalize on trends.
  • Premium Prices: Celebrity branding can often mean a higher price tag without necessarily superior ingredients.
  • Over-Saturation: The influx of celebrity brands means fierce competition, which may impact product innovation and consistency over time.

Celebrity Brands and Sustainability

Sustainability has become an essential factor in beauty, with consumers more aware of the environmental impact of their choices. Some celebrity brands are making strides toward eco-friendly packaging and ingredients, but the industry is still criticized for excess packaging, plastic use, and energy-intensive processes.

Brands like Rare Beauty have been vocal about reducing waste and supporting mental health initiatives. However, the overall sustainability impact of celebrity brands varies significantly, with others lagging in commitments toward reducing environmental footprints.

Are Celebrity Beauty Brands Here to Stay?

The celebrity beauty brand trend shows no sign of fading. For many, these brands have delivered on promises, introducing quality products that align with their audiences’ values and beauty standards. As consumers become more discerning, however, brands are increasingly held to high standards regarding quality, inclusivity, and ethics.

Ultimately, for beauty fans, the question becomes whether the quality of the product lives up to the hype. While some celebrity brands have earned high marks for inclusivity and quality, others fall short, leaning heavily on celebrity status to drive sales. The key is to look beyond the name and assess the value based on performance, ingredients, and the brand’s ethical commitments.

In 2024, celebrity beauty brands have shaped the landscape of cosmetics, but the demand for quality and transparency means that only those committed to delivering true value are likely to endure in an increasingly competitive market.

Luxe.It.Fwd is Australia's best online luxury consignment boutique.